View Single Post
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 06-21-2008, 02:09 AM
lurkswithin's Avatar
lurkswithin lurkswithin is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Texas
Posts: 1,233
lurkswithin has a spectacular aura aboutlurkswithin has a spectacular aura aboutlurkswithin has a spectacular aura about


Originally Posted by Wombat View Post
On one of my computers I have two Samsung hard drives on the same 80 connector ide cable, set as Master and Slave, and two Samsung dvd burners set as Master and Slave on it's own separate 80 connector ide cable.

I have not noticed any ill effects by doing this sort of setup in the last three years I have been doing this...

No, there won't be any ill effects...and it would depend on what a person was doing whether or not there would be any truely noticeable differences either. Also it is dependent on whether one is using 32 bit or 64 bit technology as Mr. Wombat does. Which is why you don't see any ill effects . without getting too technical 64 bit works the IDE controller differently than 32 bit technology!

Originally Posted by Gswiss View Post
BTW, is there really that much of an improvement in throughput when you mix dvd reader and disk? Is it simply because you have the 2 disks on different controllers?.
The IDE controllers have 2 0 and channel 1....and you can attach either optical drives or harddrives to either channel and in any configuration and believe it or not either channel can be designated master or slave without any ill effects (not true with older computers configurations)

With only two channels and 1 controller....the issue is that data transfer can only be made on one channel at a time. so if data is being used on channel 0 then channel 1 is mute till the data transfer on channel 0 is complete then channel 0 becomes mute and data is transfered on channel 1.

If two harddrives are connected to one IDE controller then data transmitions are intermitted especially when transfering data between each other. Now if the two harddrives are set up on different IDE controllers they can basically communicate between each other at almost twice the speed of the other set up because they can communicate simultaneously.

This becomes true for optical drives as well....
if you have a CDrom and a CDrw on the same IDE controller and you use them to copy discs then the copying takes a longer amount of time (disc to disc) because the disc must wait on each other . If set on different IDE controllers then they communicate at the same time.

On faster computers one may not see much difference but on slower computers there will be a remarkable difference.

This is actually what led to the developement of SATA controllers. All SATA basically is, is an IDE controller with a single channel forcing each device to transfer data faster.

Hope that clears it up a bit!

Last edited by lurkswithin; 06-21-2008 at 02:15 AM..
Reply With Quote